Best Syrup For Pancakes: Check Our Top 9 Picks Now!

What does a fluffy stack of pancakes remind you of? If you ask me, the first thing I'll reach for is a rich delicious syrup. 

I think the drizzle of sweet syrup is what makes pancakes truly special. Don't you agree? And a food lover would only want the best pancake syrups.

So, you have decided to get a new bottle of syrup. But the grocery store has rows and rows of syrups featuring different flavors and prices. And the number of pancake syrup brands is making you overwhelmed.

Don't give up just yet! To bring you the cream of the crop, I have reviewed 9 of the top pancake syrups available in the market.

Read on to find out all you need to know about pancake syrups. From different types to various flavors, I have discussed everything to help you in finding the finest there is.

So, let's dive in.

Types of Pancake Syrup

A stack of pancakes is simply not complete without syrup dripping all over it. But to find a good pancake syrup, first, you need to know all the different types of syrups.

To start off, there are two kinds of pancake syrup. Organic maple syrup and flavored pancake syrups.

1. Organic Maple Syrup

Organic maple syrup is made from the sap of maple trees. They are rich in minerals, antioxidants, and loads of sugar. Yes, maple syrup has about 66% sugar in it.

There are types inside this category too! All maple syrups are termed grade A now. And they are divided by color.

A. Golden Color-Delicate Taste:

This maple syrup is produced during the early harvest. And it features the mildest flavor and beautiful golden color. This is great with buttermilk pancakes, ice-creams, and fruit salads.

B. Amber Color-Rich Taste:

You will get clear rich maple flavor from this one. It's great for baked goods as it has a stronger flavor than the golden one.

C. Dark Color-Robust Taste:

If you prefer deep strong maple flavor, then go for this one. It is produced later in the harvest. This variant is mostly used for pies, marinades, and glazes.

D. Very Dark-Strong Taste:

This syrup has the most intense maple flavor. So intense that it's almost molasses-like. It's somewhat exclusively used by candy makers.

2. Flavored Pancake Syrups

Flavored syrups are primarily produced using corn syrup. These pancake syrups also include different flavorings, colors, and preservatives. The most popular flavors are maple, caramel, and butter.

However, the healthier syrups substitute corn syrup for vegetable, chicory root, or other soluble fibers. And these are sweetened with monk fruit, stevia leaf, or erythritol.

The main benefit of flavored pancake syrups is that they are relatively cheaper than pure maple syrup. Also, you get Keto, vegan, sugar-free, and low-calorie options.

Top 9 Best Pancake Syrups On The Market in 2022

1. Butternut Mountain Pure Vermont Maple Syrup

When it comes to pancake syrups, I'm on the pure maple syrup team. Nothing compares to the pure and rich sweetness of maple syrup on pancakes.

And what can be better than a maple syrup produced in Vermont? Yes, the Butternut Mountain Farm's pure Vermont maple syrup gives you the 100% authentic taste.

Decades of experience in maple syrup production is what makes this syrup so good. From sap collection to producing the richly flavored syrup, every step is done with utmost care to present you with this sweet elixir.

If you love the natural maple flavor, then definitely go for this one. The prominent maple flavor of this GRADE A syrup makes this the best maple syrup for pancakes.

It will complement not only your pancakes but also tons of other foods. To name a few, you can enjoy it with beverages, breakfast cereal, fruit salad, baked veggies, and grilled meat and fish.

Let's not forget the super convenient packaging. These 32 fluid-ounce jugs are surprisingly lightweight. So, they are easier to carry and pour.

That's not all, the packaging is made of BPA-free plastic. Meaning the flavor stays fresh and delicious for longer.

This versatile, budget-friendly, yet high-quality maple syrup will definitely fulfill all your maple syrup cravings.

Highlighted Features:

• This syrup is enriched with minerals and antioxidants.
• It is a Grade A maple syrup featuring rich amber color.
• You can use it with a variety of foods and beverages.
• Features light maple flavor with a hint of natural vanilla.
• Available in an environment-friendly BPA-free jug.

2. Lakanto Sugar Free Maple Flavored Syrup

Most people love the taste of traditional maple syrup with their pancakes. But let's be honest, they are high in calories and carbs. Hence, not suitable for people trying to follow a healthy diet.

Are you looking for a healthy alternative to maple syrup too? Then look no further! The Lakanto Maple Flavored Syrup is the healthiest pancake syrup available in the market.

This pancake syrup has zero sugar in it. In fact, it is sweetened with non-GMO monk fruit extract. So, if you prefer tasting sugar-free pancake syrup, this will be great for you.

What's more, with this you can enjoy the taste of maple syrup without consuming tons of calories. Because it only has one net carb per serving and lower calories than real maple syrup.

On top of that this syrup will be suitable for all types of natural diets. Meaning people following Keto, candida, vegan, paleo, or low carb diets can all enjoy the smooth delicious taste of maple.

That's not all! Even diabetic people can bring back sweetness to their pancakes with this sugar-free syrup. And that too without increasing their glycemic levels! Jumpstart your healthy lifestyle with the Lakanto all-natural maple-flavored pancake syrup.

Highlighted Features:

• A gluten-free and low-carb pancake syrup.
• Made from non-GMO monk fruit and vegetable fiber.
• Supports a wide range of dietary plans.
• It does not contain any sugar.
• Can be used as a sweetener with a variety of foods.

3. Mrs. Butterworth's Syrup

Next, we have the pancake syrup I'm pretty sure most of us enjoyed while growing up. Yes, it's none other than Mrs. Butterworth's Syrup.

Truth be told, there are tons of corn sugar pancake syrups available on the market. But what makes Mrs. Butterworth's syrup stand out from the crowd is its extraordinary flavor.

There is a buttery smooth texture in this syrup. Like a cherry on top of the cake, it even has a hint of honey along with maple flavor.

The unique flavor profile and texture of this syrup complements pancakes and waffles excellently. Some users go as far as to say this is the best syrup for waffles.

If you want quality pancake syrup, you won't find one better than this. This syrup has been making our pancakes mouth-watering since 1961.

What's more, they use less than two percent of artificial preservatives. The original packaging is reminiscent of childhood memories for many. It also allows you to enjoy a delicious slow pour. This 128 ounce of pure happiness is an excellent buy for the entire family.

Highlighted Features:

• Maple and honey flavored syrup.
• Made with high fructose corn syrup.
• Known for its unique buttery texture.
• It contains 20 calories per serving.
• Available in a one-gallon family pack.

4. ChocZero's Maple Syrup for Pancakes

You probably how addictive the sugary sweet maple syrup can be. But we can all agree that too much of that sugary goodness is not really great for our health.

Hence, many are looking for sugar-free alternatives to sweeten their pancakes. And for that, ChocZero's Maple Syrup is an excellent option.

This sugar-free syrup has been termed by many the best syrup for pancakes. Want to know what makes it so good?

Well, first of all, this syrup has a tantalizing smooth texture. Along with that, you get to enjoy a pronounced maple flavor. The combination of these makes this truly delicious.

And all that without gaining the extra weight. Yes, this caramelly goodness includes natural vegetable fiber and monk fruit extract. As a result, there is only one gram net carb per serving of this sugar-free syrup.

Moreover, the manufacturers ensure that it's free from artificial preservatives, soy, sugar alcohol, and GMOs. So, you can rest assured about the quality of this syrup.

Another key point is the thickness of this syrup. ChocZero doesn't add any water or filler in their syrups. Hence, you get to enjoy naturally thick syrup to make every pancake epic.

Let's not forget that this syrup can be enjoyed with more than just pancakes. Now, you can bring back sweetness to all your meals without derailing from Keto or low-carb diets.

Highlighted Features:

• A delicious sucralose-free pancake syrup.
• Sweetened with natural monk fruit extract.
• It has a lusciously thick consistency.
• Great for Keto and low carbohydrate diets.
• Does not spike glycemic index.

5. So Nourished Keto Pancake Syrup

There are tons of benefits to following the ketogenic diet. But it's equally difficult as you need to comply with strict dietary guidelines too.

Many think you need to give up delicious pancake syrups once you start Keto. As maple syrup has 66% sugar, it's not Keto-friendly at all.

Fortunately, the ‘So Nourished Keto Maple Syrup’ exists. This maple flavored pancake syrup will let you relish your pancakes without derailing you from the Keto diet.

That's not all. People following a vegan, low-sugar, or low-calorie diet can also enjoy this syrup. Why? Because this sugar-free syrup only contains 1g carb and 20 calories per serving.

Artificial sweeteners like sucralose can affect your digestive health. But So Nourished uses natural sweeteners that preserve your gut health.

The combination of erythritol, monk fruit, and stevia leaf extract ensures perfect sweetness. The addition of erythritol gives it the consistency of actual maple syrup.

On top of that, they use chicory root fiber. This ensures that your glycemic index won't spike. So, diabetic people can enjoy it with their pancakes. This Keto-friendly syrup will let you indulge in the sweetness without any guilt.

Highlighted Features:

• This syrup provides 9g fiber per serving.
• It is sweetened with three natural sweeteners.
• You only get 20 calories from 2 tbsp syrup.
• Known as a low-glycemic syrup.
• Great for the ketogenic and gluten-free diet.

6. Walden Farms Sweet Syrups

Bored of having the same syrup with your pancakes? Then, this five-pack Walden Farms Sweet Syrups is for you.

To make your breakfast exciting every day, Walden Farms has brought a package with five delicious flavored pancake syrups. Yes, you will get to enjoy chocolate, blueberry, strawberry, caramel, and pancake-flavored syrups.

Now, you can jazz up your pancake with whatever flavor you want. Moreover, fruit salads, parfaits, smoothies, coffee tasting everything will be more exciting with these syrups.

These syrups are completely free of calories. These syrups don't have any sugar, gluten, carb, or cholesterol. Meaning you get to indulge in sweet delights while maintaining a healthy lifestyle.

What's more, the fruity flavors are natural and fresh. Even the coloring was done using natural ingredients like purple sweet potato.

Flavored syrups sometimes leave a weird after-taste. But you won't get any complaints about that with these syrups. The absence of sugar alcohol removes that problem.

Walden Farms have been producing healthy pancake syrups for over 40 years. So, you can be sure of getting high-quality flavorful syrups.

Overall, if you want to follow a healthy diet without giving up sweetness, get these syrups. They boast 0g net carb per serving. This package is truly a dream come true for pancake syrup lovers.

Highlighted Features:

• The pack includes five flavored pancake syrups.
• All syrups are completely calorie-free.
• These are sweetened with sucralose.
• Comes with FDA certification.
• Brings delightful variety to your meals.

7. 365 by WFM Organic Maple Syrup

Pure maple syrup has more antioxidants and minerals than honey. And it can help you to improve and preserve your bone health, cell formation, and metabolism.

However, you can only get these benefits from pure maple syrup. And that's what 365 by WFM Maple Syrup gives you.

This maple syrup is made only from the sap of high-quality maple trees. Hence, every spoonful of syrup gives you nutrients such as calcium, potassium, and iron.

Climate Friendly Pledge has certified this syrup as 100% organic. It's also USDA and QAI certified. So, you can be sure that it doesn't include any GMO or preservatives.

That's not all, this maple syrup is vegan and completely fat-free. Therefore, you can indulge in the robust dark taste of this syrup without guilt.

Let's not forget the gorgeous glass bottle packaging of this syrup. This 12-ounce bottle of goodness can be a great gift for family and friends too.

Overall, the authentic dark maple flavor and silky texture make this a great flavor enhancer in pancakes and waffles.

Highlighted Features:

• Produced from organic maple trees.
• It includes 110 calories per serving.
• Climate Pledge Friendly product.
• This features a dark robust maple flavor.
• Labeled vegan and fat-free.

8. Log Cabin Country Kitchen Syrup

I know organic maple syrups are the best. However, they are also ridiculously expensive. So, not everyone can afford them.

But that doesn't mean you'll miss out on pancake syrup. The Log Cabin Country Kitchen Syrup brings you the deliciousness of pancake syrup at an affordable price.

It features a decadent butter flavor. Your pancakes and waffles will be elevated to restaurant-level with this syrup.

What's more, this syrup is not that thick. So, you can use it as a flavor enhancer in beverages and baked goods. It will be great for people who love the mild sweetness and thin consistency in their syrup.

Log Cabin is one of the oldest manufacturers of flavored pancake syrups. And this 36-ounce bottle with buttery goodness will definitely remind you of childhood breakfasts.

Overall, this pancake syrup is a great option for people looking for a budget-friendly option. You will get 50% extra in this bottle. So, every breakfast will be exciting with this.

Highlighted Features:

• This syrup is made from corn.
• It has notes of maple and butter flavor.
• You get 210 calories from one serving.
• Available in a 36 fl oz plastic bottle.
• Works great as a flavor enhancer.

9. Sugar Bob's Smoked Syrup

Since we are at the end of the top pancake syrup reviews, it’s upon me to finish the list with a unique syrup. And I may have saved the best tasting pancake syrup for the last.

And that is the Sugar Bob's Smoked Maple Syrup. As the name suggests, this is not your plain maple syrup. It includes a smoky flavor to make your every meal memorable.

Get ready to experience a flavor bomb. Because this rich, dark, and smoky maple syrup will change everything you know about pancake syrups.

Sugar Bob's manufacturers produce this syrup from the high-quality maple trees of Vermont. After that, they infuse hardwood smoke into this dark thick maple syrup. So, you get a maple syrup that's sweet, smoky, and 100% pure.

Another great thing about this syrup is that you can enjoy it with a wide range of foods. The unique flavor will enhance your marinades, sauces, glazes, and more.

That's not all. People who look for all-organic products will be happy with this syrup too. Because it is free of any preservatives or GMOs. However, as it does not have any artificial additives, make sure to keep it in the fridge once opened.

If you want something more from your maple syrup, definitely try out this one.

Highlighted Features:

• This maple syrup features a rich smokiness.
• You can use it for different culinary dishes.
• It includes 50 calories per serving.
• Comes in a 250ml glass bottle.
• Completely preservative-free syrup.

Comparison Chart for Top Tasting Pancake Syrup

Syrup For Pancakes Buying Guide

Type

The first thing you need to decide is what type of pancake syrup you want to purchase. Because there are things you need to consider for pure maple syrups that won't be necessary if you choose flavored syrups.

Do you want traditional maple?

Or do you like a variety of flavors like chocolate, caramel, or butter. There are various types of pancake syrups available in the market. If you aren't sure, you can try out mini-sized syrups of different flavors.

Grade And Color

If you have chosen pure maple syrup, grade and color are something to keep in mind. In the new grade system, all maple syrup is grade A. The difference in flavor comes from the color.

Golden color means light maple flavor. Amber means rich maple taste. After that comes dark color with robust taste. The most intense maple flavor is found in the very dark-colored maple syrup.

Uses

Another important thing to consider is how you'll be using the maple syrup. If you want to enjoy it with pancakes and waffles, the best pancake syrups will be the mildly flavored ones.

But if grilling and baking are on your mind too, go for a syrup that has more strong maple flavor.

Budget

When it comes to pure maple syrups, a higher price doesn't necessarily mean greater quality. You can get flavorful maple syrups from local farms at a much better price. Also, try buying from wholesale stores if you want to save some money.

If you want to filter from hundreds of options according to your budget, try Amazon. Online platforms like Amazon often offer great deals with the convenience of doorstep delivery.

Sugar-Free

If you want sugar-free pancake syrup, forget pure maple syrup. But don't be disheartened, because there are some great sugar-free syrup options on the market now.

You can choose maple-flavored or other flavored syrups that are sweetened with natural sweeteners. Natural sweeteners include erythritol, fruit extracts, stevia, etc.

Try to go for ones that avoid artificial sweeteners like sucralose. Because they are not ideal for your digestive system.

Dietary Restrictions

Most popular diets have restrictions for carbohydrates, GMOs, and artificial additives. So, read the label of the syrup you want to buy. Does it contain Keto-friendly, vegan, and natural ingredients?

There are some great Keto, low-calorie, vegan pancake syrups available now. Therefore, choose based on your preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What Is The Difference Between Dark And Amber Maple Syrup?

Answer: The dark maple syrup has the most intense maple flavor. It's mostly used in cooking. But the amber syrup has a rich, yet less intense maple flavor. People prefer it in beverages and pancakes.

2. Is Maple Syrup Healthy?

Answer: Pure maple syrup is considered healthier than regular sugar. It also includes more nutrients than honey. But still, you should use them sparingly because maple syrup does spike insulin levels.

3. How Are Sugar-Free Syrups Sweetened?

Answer: Sugar-free syrups can be sweetened by plant-based or artificial sweeteners. Sugar alcohols like erythritol, sorbitol, and xylitol are the most popular. These syrups can also be sweetened with fruit extracts and stevia.

4. Is Pancake Syrup Vegan?

Answer: This depends on which pancake syrup you are talking about. 100% pure maple syrups that don't have added preservatives are vegan. However, if the syrup is flavored, make sure it uses natural flavors and sweeteners.

5. How Is Maple Syrup Prepared?

Answer: Maple syrup is made from the sap of maple trees. The sap is filtered, boiled, and then infused with flavor and color. About 40 gallons of maple sap is used to produce only 1-gallon syrup.

6. Do I Need To Store My Maple Syrup In The Fridge?

Answer: Unopened maple syrup has two years of shelf life. And it doesn't need to be refrigerated. Once you have opened the bottle, you need to keep it in the fridge. It will stay fresh for a few months when refrigerated.

Final Word

Pancakes and syrups are a duo that's incomplete without each other. These syrups also have various other culinary uses. However, the plethora of syrup choices makes choosing one quite challenging.

Hopefully, the reviews of the best syrup for pancakes have helped you in finding your ideal breakfast companion.

This list includes both pure maple syrups and flavored ones. I also covered products for people with different diets, budgets, and flavor preferences.

So, what are you waiting for? Choose the one that suits your needs and indulge in your fluffy pancakes with the delicious syrups. Wish you a life full of sweetness!

Also Read:

• How to keep pancakes warm (4 simple ways discussed).
• Get a good quality sprinkles for funfetti cake from our list.